What's your idea of going in to a government office in India ?
In continuation with my writings on the 'in between' phase of my life, here are some observations from my end.
My idea of a government office in India (read Kerala - my home state) has been mostly fed in by friends, peers, media, TV and Cinema and so on. And my interaction with them in some remote form or the other during my school and college days to get some certificates issued. I had never been to any Govt office to actually get something done, because it was never the norm. There was / is a middleman to do everything you want from a Govt office. I had also been freshly updated of the gory rituals by the movie " Sivaji", which I had seen some months before I left US.
When I returned back home, and started my adventures of going to various Govt offices for setting up my enterprise I found some remarkable differences from the stereotypes I had in mind.
I had been to Kerala State Electricity Board for getting some certification for my CTs ( I am yet to figure out what that really means ). According to them this was the first time a real end customer had gone to this facility ( which excels in testing transformers ) with the request of testing 3 CTs. Our CTs fit in to the Jeans' pockets and the engineers were wondering how they would test such a small CT (the transformers which were in the yard there were as big a room). But after half an hour of analysis they told us to pay Rs 60 and leave the CTs there, they would be tested and given in a day's time. Do you know how much a 'consultant' estimated this job to cost ? Rs 25,000.
My observation in this incident is as follows.
-- Firstly I refused to pay the middle man that amount of money , who was waiting to rip off this guy who just landed from the US and for whom money is not supposed to a big issue. I mustered the courage to go and explain the necessity to the concerned officials.
-- Secondly, the officials were willing to listen to my particular case and earnestly wanted to help me out, even though they did not know the process of testing such small pieces of equipment. These things never come to them for testing it seems, and I was to take them to a different center at least 60 KMs away.
It can be two things. The officials really feel a genuine interest to promote the country's vision, or they did not want to take the hassle of asking any bribe to two youngsters who seemed determined and were very straight forward with their request. I would love to believe the former, I will support it with another incident I came across.
I had to finish off some property tax related stuff in the Taluk Office. I could not understand half of what was being said in those forms, and promptly my family had arranged for a consultant. His fee was 7500 to get all things "ready" plus the tax I had to pay to the Taluk Office. I again said I am not going to pay this guy and thought I would do it myself. Everyone was the opinion that there is no way I am going to meet the Thahsildar and get this done in one day's time. I had gone anyways, met the Thahsildar ( I could not have done this in the US with out an appointment) got the taxation issues sorted out, got the order to pay the tax......all done in ten minutes time. he was even kid enough to ask if I needed an installment scheme to pay the tax.........some experience I would have never got if I went through these middle men, who wanted to rip me)
But where I had an expected experience was at the DMV / RTO Office when I purchased my Car. I just could not get my vehicle registered by going alone with the required forms, the clerk there sent me again and again in want of so many different forms.......I did not want to give up, but due to the lack of time and energy, and having other higher priorities I gave this one out to a consultant, who charged me a nominal Rs 500 and got the registration done for me.
So I guess, though my observations may be disjointed, but being an optimist, I see a changing trend.....a changing trend towards the better way of doing things. I am happy to see that the Govt systems have not completely gone out of whack and that there is definitely hope for a better tomorrow.
Tuesday, March 11, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
6 comments:
Hi,
I accidentally came by your blog while searching for something else altogether. I liked it of course but what's more baffling is that I think I know you.
My name is Deepthi. I was in Bangalore for a long time. I am not sure whether you are the same Mohan that I use to call Mohan etta.
Do excuse me if you are indeed not the person I am referring to.
But loved both blogs. Great writing! :)
Yup ! Gundu this is Mohan....how you doing. Connect with me at mohan.kan@gmail.com
mohan:> liked this. Sometimes we take things for granted and do not want to go the extra mile. am glad that you tried and succeeded. thsi should be an eye opener to folks who tout kerala as a bad investment destination.
Mohan: One of the very few instances of someone not falling into the stereotype of buying into claims that nothing gets done in the government office at Kerala.
I have had numerous instances of getting my caste certificates from the Taluk offices at Ernakulam and Kottayam and I must say the effort required was around 10 minutes with absolutely no hassles.
I believe there is a certain amount of disdain shown to Kerala, probably cz it doesn't compare with the artificial gloss of say a B'lore or a Hyderabad. The sad part is emigrant malayalees are the ones who love to spread the rumours of labour militancy in Kerala affecting way of life and how Kerala should be the last place one should go for investment.
Good write-up, Mohan.
Cheers,
Rahul
@redwaterstew...thanks. That
s true, Kerala is not as bad as people make it out to be. There is a general laid back attitude towards things, and urgency is a little unknwon around here... but what the hell , may be that was how it was supposed to be :-) I am enjoying it anyways.
@ReadnRyte...thanks. Yes, these are very rare moments, but definitely achievable. We need to act ignorant about their existing practices, then they become open to things.
Post a Comment